[review in f-sharp] Write On, Irving Berlin! by Leslie Kimmelman and David C. Gardner

“Blue skies, smiling at me, nothing but blue skies do I see.” ~ Irving Berlin (1926)

If you’re American (or a music lover anywhere else in the world), you probably know Irving Berlin’s music — even if you don’t think you do. He wrote for and about us — the average American citizen — whom he considered to be “the real soul of the country.” He wrote from the heart, easily capturing ours. George Gershwin considered Berlin to be the greatest songwriter who ever lived.

His songs are exquisite cameos of perfection, and each one of them is as beautiful as its neighbor. Irving Berlin remains, I think, America’s Schubert. But apart from his genuine talent for song-writing, Irving Berlin has had a greater influence upon American music than any other one man. It was Irving Berlin who was the very first to have created a real, inherent American music.

At Berlin’s 100th Birthday Celebration at Carnegie Hall in 1988, Walter Cronkite said:

[Berlin] helped write the story of this country, capturing the best of who we are and the dreams that shape our lives.

So when we celebrate major holidays, Berlin is there (“Easter Parade,” “White Christmas”). He’s with us when we watch a classic musical on the telly (“Top Hat,” “Puttin’ on the Ritz,” “Annie Get Your Gun”). Since many of America’s most popular singers have recorded a Berlin tune or two (Frank Sinatra, Barbra Streisand, Rosemary Clooney, Willie Nelson, Bing Crosby), all of us would have likely heard at least one of Berlin’s songs somewhere, sometime.

Most notably, whenever we gather to honor our men and women in uniform, we sing Berlin’s signature song, “God Bless America,” the lyrics of which we’ve known by heart since childhood.

Last month, a new picture book biography was released that introduces young readers to Berlin’s extraordinary life and legacy. Write On, Irving Berlin! by Leslie Kimmelman and David C. Gardner (Sleeping Bear Press, 2018), traces Berlin’s life from the time he arrived in America with his family in 1893 until his death at age 101. He wrote some 1500 songs, comprising a substantial part of the Great American Songbook.

We first meet five-year-old Israel Isadore Baline (“Izzy”) as he arrives at Ellis Island with his parents and five siblings. Like many other Jewish immigrants, the Baline family had fled their homeland to escape the Russian pogroms. They settled in New York’s crowded, bustling Lower East Side to begin their new life in America.

Young Izzy attended school but was considered a poor student because he tended to daydream and often sang to himself. Back in Russia, his father had been a cantor, so it was no surprise that Izzy’s head was full of music. When he was 13, Izzy’s father died, so he dropped out of school and left home to lessen the burden on his family. He made money by doing what he loved to do: sing!

He sang in saloons. He sang in the choruses of shows. He sang as he waited tables in restaurants.

He may not have been a good student, but he had learned English. He began to write song lyrics, and made 37 cents for his first sale, “Marie from Sunny Italy.” It wasn’t very good, but Izzy, now calling himself “I. Berlin,” kept practicing, getting better and better, making up tunes as well as lyrics. He landed a job with a music publisher in Tin Pan Alley, penning his first big hit, “Alexander’s Ragtime Band.”

Berlin married and became an American citizen. Sadly, his wife Dorothy died a few months after their wedding. Berlin threw himself into his songwriting. When he was drafted into the U.S. Army during WWI, he wrote for the soldiers, cheering them up, boosting morale.

After the war, he remarried and wrote a beautiful love song for his new wife Ellin, called “Always.” Berlin continued to write song after song. He wrote everywhere — in taxicabs, in elevators, in the bathtub, staying up all night to compose. There were so many tunes in his head, and he could write songs in a flash. In the days leading up to WWII, Berlin polished a song he had written 20 years earlier, “God Bless America,” which became a HUGE hit. This was followed by “White Christmas,” another hit that resonated deeply with soldiers stationed overseas who were missing home. It reminded them of what they were fighting for.

Though he was too old to enlist, Berlin “served his country” by taking his show on the road, entertaining troops stationed all over the world. Ahead of his time, he assembled a completely integrated cast of black and white soldiers, refusing to perform anywhere that didn’t welcome all of them (the U.S. Armed Forces didn’t integrate until years later). Millions enjoyed Berlin’s shows and he donated all proceeds to wartime charities.

Throughout his life, nothing stopped Berlin from writing. “He never ran out of ideas,” continuing to compose new songs for new shows after the war ended. His story is inspiring not only for the wide appeal and longevity of his work, but for who he was as a human being. Many were angry that it was a Jewish immigrant who wrote the most well loved Christian holiday songs, and that the man who wrote the beloved patriotic anthem “God Bless America” wasn’t even born in America. But one would be hard pressed to find anyone who loved this country more. From the beginning, Berlin donated all proceeds from the song to the Boy and Girl Scouts of America.

Moreover, his success proves that a good song is a good song, with its ability to move the listener and communicate something meaningful in a simple, direct way. Music transcends race, social class, and ethnicity; it’s the reason it’s aptly called the universal language.

Kimmelman’s engaging narrative spotlights Berlin’s tireless work ethic, his natural born musical talent, and his boundless love for songwriting. She showed how much Berlin loved America, proving it time and again by the exemplary life he lived, and what he wholeheartedly gave all of us with his music. He was eternally grateful for the opportunities America afforded him. He was able to make a good life for himself and his family after starting out penniless and was entirely self taught when it came to music.

Gardner’s soft watercolors provide interesting details about each stage of Berlin’s life, giving us a good sense of time and place. I especially enjoyed seeing the crowded streets of the Lower East Side, Berlin busy composing at the keyboard and in the bathtub, and the various settings where his music was performed and enjoyed. I also liked how Gardner used the recurring Statue of Liberty motif to highlight the immigrant experience. As Berlin gazes at her in the distance, we can easily imagine his gratitude.

Young readers will love Berlin’s gumption and persistence, and will want to learn more about his life and music. Ultimately, Write On, Irving Berlin! is about more than the story of one revered musician. In this day and age of exclusion and xenophobia, it is a good reminder that we are a nation of immigrants, and it is important to honor those who have made invaluable contributions to the fabric of society. Berlin’s music is now part of our cultural DNA. I can’t imagine a world without “White Christmas,” “Easter Parade,” or “God Bless America,” which is celebrating its 100th Anniversary this year.

The back matter includes an Author’s Note with a few more interesting tidbits: Berlin couldn’t read or write music, and composed all his songs in the key of F-sharp, because he only played the black keys on the piano. He was also one of the founders of ASCAP (American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers), and was awarded the Medal of Merit from President Truman and the Congressional Medal of Honor from President Eisenhower.


written by Leslie Kimmelman
illustrated by David C. Gardner
published by Sleeping Bear Press (May 2018)
Picture Book Biography for ages 6-9, 32 pp.

♥ Find out more about the book in this interview with Leslie at Deborah Kalb’s site.


Finally, we must hear a couple of Irving Berlin tunes. First, here’s Berlin himself singing “God Bless America.” Though the song is almost synonymous with Kate Smith, who introduced it on Armistice Day 1938, I found Berlin’s 1968 performance on the Ed Sullivan Show with the Scouts especially moving:


And here’s “White Christmas” with Bing Crosby and Marjorie Reynolds, from the 1942 movie “Holiday Inn” (Martha Mears’s vocal was dubbed in for Reynolds). Crosby’s version of the song is the world’s best selling Christmas single (100 million+ copies worldwide).


Poignant sidenote: “White Christmas” was first heard on the radio in December 1941, just 18 days after Japan bombed Pearl Harbor. That winter, Armed Forces radio played it repeatedly for soldiers stationed overseas. When Bing Crosby performed for the troops, he hesitated to sing it because it made them sad, yearning for home — but they always requested it.

Few knew that the song had a different meaning for Berlin himself. As a Russian Jew, he of course didn’t celebrate Christmas, yet each Christmas he and his wife had their own ritual — they visited the grave of their son, who had died on Christmas Day 1928 when he was just three weeks old. Though little backstory is known about the actual composing of “White Christmas,” some speculate that its melancholy tone may be attributed to Berlin remembering his son.



Thanks to everyone for reading my interview with Astronaut Clayton Anderson last week. We are pleased to announce that the winner of a brand new copy of A is for Astronaut is:



👏 👏 👏 👏 👏

Please send your snail mail address to readermail (at) jamakimrattigan (dot) com to receive your book!!


Kiesha Shepard is hosting the Roundup at Whispers from the Ridge. Skip on over to check out the full menu of poetic goodness being served up in the blogosphere this week. Enjoy your weekend!

*Interior spreads posted by permission of the publisher, text copyright © 2018 Leslie Kimmelman, illustrations © 2018 David C. Gardner, published by Sleeping Bear Press. All rights reserved.

**This post contains Amazon Affiliate links. When you purchase something using a link on this site, Jama’s Alphabet Soup receives a small referral fee at no cost to you. Thanks for your support!

***Copyright © 2018 Jama Rattigan of Jama’s Alphabet Soup. All rights reserved.

35 thoughts on “[review in f-sharp] Write On, Irving Berlin! by Leslie Kimmelman and David C. Gardner

    1. I really enjoyed learning more about Berlin’s life — and was surprised to find he had written many songs I didn’t realize he had written. 🙂


  1. The book is on the way from the library, Jama, and now you’ve made me want to see it even more. What an amazing life he led in song, always singing even in school, learning himself when he had to quit school. It is sad to hear that some didn’t like that he wrote God Bless America & wasn’t even born here! Immigrants seem to have to fight every step of the way! Thanks for the beautiful post!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I know you’ll enjoy the book, Linda. I didn’t realize before Berlin was self taught in music. He certainly was born with a knack for songwriting — he was doubly talented to have written both music and lyrics.


    1. His is an inspiring and interesting story. Good to see new picture books about Berlin’s life this year (I know of 2 others besides this one).


  2. Oh, Jama, where do I begin? This post is so appealing! I adore Irving Berlin’s music. I enjoyed your backstory and review of this incredible picture book! I have the soundtrack to the movie “Holiday Inn,” and it is certainly one of my favorites around the holidays. Berlin’s musical scores are definitely a hit with me! Thank you ever so much for sharing!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think we kind of take for granted the place Berlin’s music holds in all of our lives — it was there from our childhoods, always present in many ways as time went on, so it’s nice that kids will now have a chance to learn about his life with this book.


  3. “In this day and age of exclusion and xenophobia, it is a good reminder that we are a nation of immigrants, and it is important to honor those who have made invaluable contributions to the fabric of society.” Truth.

    Thanks for this inspirational peek into warp and weft of American culture!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. A spectacular post, Jama! Both the book and your post are a celebration of the beloved contributions of one very famous immigrant. At this time, we seem to sorely need reminders of the many ways immigrants have enriched American life and the world. The backstory for “A White Christmas” is poignant. Loved seeing Irving Berlin sing “God Bless America.” This looks like a wonderful book.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. We shouldn’t need reminders, but it seems we do now more than ever. I didn’t know about the “White Christmas” backstory until just recently. Good picture books inspire me to dig deeper.


  5. Oh, Jama, what a beautiful post, with so many tidbits, poignant backstories, and of course, a gorgeous picture book. Thank you!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Thanks Jama for this lovely montage of music and backstory about Irving Berlin! Fascinating to find out that he couldn’t write or read music thought he created so many gorgeous songs–and sometimes in the bathtub too. The book looks wonderful and I definitely would like to spend some time with it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. He definitely had a gift for songwriting. I hadn’t realized he couldn’t read or write music either — I think the same is true for Paul McCartney (?).


  7. Irving Berlin was my dad’s absolute favorite musician and I grew up listening to his songs. I wish he was still alive so I could share this book with him. I may have to buy it for my mom instead. Thank you!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Sounds like you and your mom would enjoy this book. Nice to hear that you grew up with Irving Berlin’s music too. 🙂


  8. As I have grown older, I’ve basically given up on contemporary music and I end up singing songs from the Great American Songbook. “Always” is one, although the chord changes are really beyond me! Thanks for the post!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I used to be up on contemporary music, but not anymore. I seem to fall back on classic rock as well as the Great American Songbook.


  9. Love this post and the inclusion of so many illustrations and clips of the songs. I’m off to request the book from the library now. We need more focus on those who capture “… the best of who we are and the dreams that shape our lives.” A powerful read for all in our current political climate.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, you’re right — both powerful and uplifting to read books like these. So glad you requested it from the library. I know you’ll enjoy it.


  10. Thank you for introducing us to this book, Jama! I’m sure I’m not the only person who feels like Irving Berlin songs were the soundtrack of their childhood. Can’t wait to get this book!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Definitely the soundtrack of my childhood too. Just read this great quote on Janis Ian’s FB page: “Art is how we decorate space, music is how we decorate time.”


  11. “Easter Parade” reminds me of my childhood for sure. Spring was a special time as is, but it also meant new shiny Easter shoes, a new dress, and, of course, a special hat. I remember going to stores to see all the hats with their little multi-colored flower sprays. We walked to church every Sunday which was about a mile. I prayed for good weather, so I didn’t have to wear a coat to hide my dress or get wet. So glad Kimmelman and Gardner wrote this book. I didn’t know much about the man. My grandparents, too, came from Russia in 1905, 1907. And I thought Bing Crosby wrote “White Christmas!!!” Not to mention “God Bless America.” Thanks again, Jama, for some living history and reminders.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for sharing your Easter memories. In many ways, I enjoyed the Easter holiday more than Christmas. And I used to envy the little girls who had winter coats (unheard of in Hawaii). 🙂


  12. I illustrated “Write On Irving Berlin!” and just wanted to say a big THANK YOU, Jama, for your generous, thoughtful review of our book.

    And I want you to know, you are the very first reviewer to “get” the motif of the Statue of Liberty and Berlin’s gratitude for his adopted country. Leslie pointed it out in her wonderful text, and I tried to squeeze every last ounce of significance out of it. Glad you noticed!

    What a great, eclectic blog you’ve got going here!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thanks so much for taking the time to read my review and comment, David — and thanks for the beautiful illustrations you created for this project! I do love your Statue of Liberty motif and how it effectively underscored Berlin’s love of country and the immigrant experience. There were so many other interesting details too (the bathtub spread is a special favorite). 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.